Middlesex Gazette
12 September 1891
FATAL ACCIDENT - INQUEST
On Monday, Mr T.J. Sworder, coroner for Hertford, held an inquest at the Queen Eleanor publichouse, Waltham Cross, touching the death of Jonathan Caten, aged 61-years, who was killed on Saturday morning at Waltham Cross. The following gentlemen composed the jury - Messrs A. Wilson, W. Paveley, J. Rule, C. Withers, J. Eaton, J. Matthews, C. Avis, J. Long, John Eaton, E. Wollard, T. Hewitt, and W. Bradstock. Mr Hewitt was appointed foreman of the jury. Acting-sergeant Amos Simpson acted as the coroner's officer, and Inspector Macdonald watched the case on behalf of the Police Commissioner. The jury, having been sworn, proceeded to view the body, after which the following evidence was adduced:-
Richard Bowyer, carman, Woodland-villas, Waltham Cross, deposed that he was in the employ of Mr John Dewey, farmer, Waltham Cross. The deceased was also in the same employ. On Friday night, about eleven o'clock, he met the deceased at the Woolpack bridge, Enfield Highway, as he was returning from London. Witness was going to London. The deceased seemed to be asleep, and witness woke him, saying, "Mind and keep awake." Deceased was quite sober to all appearance.
James Thirgood, greengrocer, Waltham Cross, stated that at 12.30 on Saturday morning he was retiring to rest, when he heard a noise out on the highway. He said to his wife, "There is a cart gone over. Did you hear that bang?" He then went out, and could see nothing, but he heard a sound as of a man groaning. He walked along the footpath, and when he arrived at Mr Dewey's gates he saw the deceased lying in the gateway. He was endeavouring to get up, but could not. Witness said to him, "How did you do this?" and the deceased replied, "It's no use telling a lie; I was dosing, and the horses turned into the yard sharp. The wheel went over my body." When he spoke to the deceased he was on his hands and knees trying to get up. Mr Dewey came up, and they took the man home.
By Mr Long: The horses went right into the yard, where they were found afterwards.
John Dewey stated that he was called about half-past twelve o'clock. He went into the yard and saw the deceased, who, in reply to questions said he went to sleep. The horses were steady ones, and the deceased had driven them for ten years. Generally speaking the deceased was a steady man.
Dr. Russell stated that he was called about a quarter past one o'clock. He went to the deceased's house in Waltham-lane, where he found him sitting in a chair with very little power to move. The deceased was suffering from shock and great pain on the right side in the lower part of the abdomen. With assistance deceased was got on to a mattress, and witness examined him. There were no bones broken, but there was a bruise just above the thigh joint, where the wheel went over him. He considered the man ill, but not critically so. He answered all questions and was quite intelligent. About half past four he was called again to see the deceased, but when he arrived he found him dead. Death was due to shock, but there might have been a small rupture of the bowels.
The Coroner, in summing up, said there was no doubt the deceased met his death by accident.
The jury returned a verdict of accidental death.